COLUMN | Naughty, naughty: Turkish shipyard in eye of Fonzi scandal, shadow fleet shenanigans and fake flag seller sanctioned at last [Offshore Accounts]

COLUMN | Naughty, naughty: Turkish shipyard in eye of Fonzi scandal, shadow fleet shenanigans and fake flag seller sanctioned at last [Offshore Accounts]
Published on: 

Consequences finally catch up with Nvidia and its long-standing scheme to sell advanced processing chips to China (seemingly in violation of US Government export controls) through a Singaporean intermediary company run by the Chinese Government-affiliated lover of former CEO Jenson Huang. However, it’s not just in Silicon Valley where perhaps people haven’t been as honest as they should have and where opaque structures mask bad behaviour.

This week, we turn our attentions to some areas of the maritime industry also caught up in litigation and scandal. There may be no glamorous femme fatales like Alice Huang, sadly, and there may be no billionaires in leather jackets caught out being unfaithful, but there is plenty to focus the mind of seafarers and shore managers alike.

Turkey shipyard troubles in Fonzi scam

Whilst the world has been watching the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, the Nvidia revelations and the American midterm elections, Turkey has been caught up in massive scandal called the Fonzi, which has seen the Capital Markets Board dissolve 131 funds managed by seven investment management companies. Fonzi is the combination of the Turkish word for fund, and a reference to Ponzi schemes, after some of the funds published returns of over 4,000 per cent in 2025, compared to a 13 per cent return for the Istanbul Stock Exchange.

Like all Ponzi schemes, the funds then spectacularly imploded and investors lost their shirts, as Farzan Ghadially has noted. The Fonzi crisis involves US$20 billion of investments, and nearly half a million Turkish retail investors have lost cash, drawn in both by the lure of the impressive returns published by the funds, and by fear of the impact of years of high inflation in Turkey on their savings. The aftermath of the scandal has seen the usual police investigations, arrests, resignations and vociferous denials from the highest levels of government.

The Financial Times has reported on the big names caught up in the scheme. Those arrested and remanded in custody include the former head of the Istanbul Stock Exchange, a former presidential adviser who claimed to have coined the “Turkish century” election slogan for President Erdoğan, former ambassadors, former central bank officials, and senior managers from leading Turkish businesses.

The scam was simple: a variant of the “pump and dumps” made famous in the Leonardo diCaprio film The Wolf of Wall Street, which Turkish fund managers appear to have seen as an instruction manual rather than as a morality tale. Fonzi funds built up concentrated positions in public listed companies with limited floats of shares. As they bought stock, they bid up the share prices of those companies, which made the asset values of their funds’ stakes look impressively high. The performance was the result not of the improved performances of the target companies, but of the squeeze on the stock prices that drove them higher.

What’s the shipping link?

Özata Denizcilik rises like Icarus then crashes

Özata Shipyard
Özata ShipyardÖzata Shipyard

If I asked you what were the most valuable shipyards in the world earlier in the year, you might have said the big Korean shipbuilders like Hanwa Ocean or HD Hyundai Heavy Industries, or perhaps the Chinese titans like COSCO or China Merchants. These are huge yards churning out huge numbers of high value vessels for big international customers.

Probably the small Turkish yard of Özata Denizcilik based in Yalova on the Sea of Marmara would not be amongst them. When it floated on the Istanbul Stock Exchange in 2024, the yard had a market capitalisation of roughly US$200 million, and it was not a particularly liquid stock, as less than one in five of its shares were publicly traded. For most of 2025, the yard was valued at less than US$100 million and the business was loss-making.

However, in April this year, some of the Fonzi funds started buying shares in the shipyard at less than 300 Turkish lira (roughly US$6) per share. The Fonzi funds carried on buying more and more of the shares at ever higher levels, meaning that next to no shares were available in the local market, as the funds owned 96 per cent of the company. As this dramatic graph shows, by end of August the company was worth over US$7 billion, based on the limited number of stocks traded. Quite an achievement for a repair yard with only 200 employees.

This stratospheric rise generated the Fonzi funds a 1,600 per cent return in five months “on paper”. At that price of over 5,000 lira (US$99) per share, Özata Denizcilik was in theory valued at more than some of the largest shipping and shipyards companies in the world. Then, in October, the stock collapsed, as panicked investors tried to withdraw funds from the Fonzi schemes, leading to a crash in the shares of the companies they held.

Crash! Stock falls 98 per cent

Özata Denizcilik stock fell 98 per cent in a few weeks. Turkey’s capital markets regulator has now filed criminal charges against 11 people, including three of its directors, over the suspected manipulation of the company’s shares. The shipyard has highlighted that the detained persons should be presumed innocent until proven guilty in court, of course, that they deny wrongdoing, inevitably, and that its own operations remain unaffected, thankfully. More widely, 400 people are subject to judicial processes in Turkey and 100 have been arrested as part of the fall-out to the Fonzi scandal.

President Erdoğan has promised even the most senior members of his party involved will be held accountable. “We do not protect those who wrong our people,” he said.

The deputy chair of his ruling AKP political party, Fatma Betül Sayan Kaya, was forced to resign after she and her husband miraculously sold 400,000 Özata shares just before the share price crashed. Ms Kaya said she has since voluntarily returned more than around US$40 million in the gains she made from the share trading. She denies receiving inside information or committing any wrongdoing, the FT reported. Of course she would.

Standard disclaimers apply. When an investment looks too good to be true, it probably is, especially in shipbuilding and ship repair, which are businesses known for low margins and lacklustre returns.

Captain Ajay Pant in the dock

The Russian "shadow fleet" tanker Smyrtos being boarded by UK forces
The Russian "shadow fleet" tanker Smyrtos being boarded by UK forcesUK Ministry of Defence

On Friday, the hearing of Ajay Pant, a 38-year-old Indian national, concluded in London, the first of several court appearances by the seafarer in the coming weeks. The ship’s captain was arrested and charged by the British authorities in connection with alleged violation of western sanctions on the sale and transport of Russian oil.

He was detained after the Aframax tanker of which he was master, the 2009-built Smyrtos, was seized by British forces in a dramatic helicopter raid in June. The ship was transiting fully laden with crude through the English Channel from the Russian port of Ust-Luga to India with a mixed Georgian and Indian crew. As per terrestrial AIS reporting, the vessel remains under detention at anchor at Weymouth Bay in the south of England, causing concern to local residents. It is owned by Zhao Yao Shipping of China.

Fair trial and no prejudicial reporting

We note that the hearing before Justice Richard Jacobs at Southwark Crown Court is under strict court-imposed restrictions, prohibiting the reporting of any information on the proceedings at this stage, but we can discuss the publicly known facts of the case, which was widely covered at the time and has its own Wikipedia page.

Captain Pant is entitled to a fair trial, and it is vital that there should be no reporting, commentary or sharing of information online that could in any way prejudice these proceedings.

Captain Pant has pleaded not guilty to an “offence contrary to regulation 46Z9B of the Russia (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (SI 2019/855) (‘the Russia Regulations’), namely maritime transportation of certain oil/oil products to and between third countries.” If convicted, he faces up to ten years in prison.

Questions bigger than one man and one ship

The case raises critical issues for seafarers more widely, especially in the tanker fleet. What can seafarers do if the circumstances of their employment change during their tour of duty, and what rights and obligations does the master of the ship have regarding compliance with foreign sanctions law?

The key challenge for seafarers that the case raises involves the status of stateless vessels, which can be seized by littoral states and lack flag state protections under the law of the sea. At the time of seizure of the vessel by British forces, Smyrtos was stateless and flagless, prosecutors have alleged. The tanker had been flying the proud flag of Cameroon since December 2025, following a reflag from that bastion of shipping excellence, Gambia, earlier last year. Unfortunately, following European Union diplomatic pressure, the Cameroonian registry kicked out 36 vessels believed to be linked to Russian and Iranian oil transport in June, including Smyrtos, hence deregistering them.

David Hammond, the founder and executive director of advocacy group Human Rights at Sea International, discusses the points raised by the Smyrtos case here.

Stateless vessels are not ones you want to command

Following the conviction of Avtandil Kalandadze, the Georgian master of the shadow tanker Bella-1/Marinara, in New York in August, the criminal case against Ajay Pant highlights the legal dangers seafarers face if they work on shadow fleet vessels.

Captain Kalandadze was sentenced to ten months in prison. Captain Pant will have his day in court and should be presumed innocent until the trial is concluded, but he has spent many months in pre-trial custody already.

If you are looking at joining a tanker flagged to an “exotic” registry like Sao Tome, Sierra Leone or Comoros, do your own research, and be sceptical. The shadow fleet might pay nice wages, but there are legal risks, especially if your voyage takes you through the territorial waters of countries that impose sanctions on Russia or Iran. After several shadow fleet vessels have been seized by western powers, the risks are apparent.

The iFact investigation of the shadow fleet managers operating in Georgia and Azerbaijan is worthy of wider circulation. As All the Manager’s Friends: The Georgian Network behind the Shadow Fleet highlighted, the owners of these firms choose opaque jurisdictions because they offer, "anonymity, weak disclosure rules, and limited regulatory scrutiny… all of which make it easier to obscure who is really operating or profiting from a vessel.”

Fitburg duo convicted in Helsinki

Fitburg at the Port of Kantvik the day after her seizure by Finnish authorities, January 1, 2026
Fitburg at the Port of Kantvik the day after her seizure by Finnish authorities, January 1, 2026MarineTraffic.com/Kim Helle

Whilst Captain Pant’s case is in process in England, the start of this month saw two convictions for in Helsinki to crewmembers involved in the notorious case of Fitburg, a Saint Vincent and the Grenadines-flagged, 132-metre-long general cargo vessel built in 2001 and now renamed Finex.  A Finnish court convicted Azerbaijani boatswain Vusal Majidov and the vessel’s master, Russian national Andrei Maksimenko, of damaging two undersea telecommunications cables in the Baltic Sea on December 31 last year, as per Helsinki Times reporting.

The Helsinki District Court found the two seamen guilty of aggravated sabotage, and the judge sentenced Maksimenko to three years and six months in prison, and the boatswain to two years and 10 months. The court also ordered them to pay over US$2 million in compensation for the costs of inspecting and repairing the cables. Ouch!

The prosecutors claimed that the ship had been dragging its anchor for up to eight hours and over 60 nautical miles in Finland’s exclusive economic zone after the vessel departed Saint Petersburg the previous day with a fully functioning windlass. Marks on the seabed showed that the anchor had been lowered in Russian waters. Even after the Finnish Coast Guard contacted the ship, the anchor continued to drag for two more hours when Majidov was on navigational watch.

In all, the anchor was dragged across nine telecommunications and electricity cables connecting Finland with other countries as well as a gas pipeline, but only two telecoms cables were damaged, in particular, those belonging to Finnish telecoms group Elisa and Swedish provider Arelion.

The case is important because the indictment did not allege that Maksimenko had explicitly ordered the anchor to be lowered. However, the court found that both defendants, who denied wrongdoing and pleaded not guilty, must have known it was dragging, something which would be obvious to most of our readers.

The officers had challenged Finland's jurisdiction because they claimed that the incidents had occurred outside Finland’s 12-nautical-mile territorial waters. However, the court rejected this argument, finding that the intentional offences had consequences in Finland and that the pair deliberately endangered infrastructure essential to society. The panel of three judges unanimously agreed the convictions following eight days of hearings in September and October.

Like Captain Pant, the accused were held before the trial, but the vessel was released and is currently in Ashdod, Israel. Lawyers for Maksimenko have indicated he will appeal the conviction.

Any readers with information on what Israel is exporting or importing with Russia on Finex are most welcome to drop us a line, as we are genuinely curious. Rather like Ireland and its aluminium exports from Aughinish Alumina, there are some decidedly off trades continuing through the Russian attacks on Ukraine and subsequent western sanctions.

Eagle S trio still fighting as appeal court rules against them

Eagle S (right), an oil tanker believed to be responsible for damaging the Estlink 2 electricity interconnector cable between Estonia and Finland on December 25, 2024
Eagle S (right), an oil tanker believed to be responsible for damaging the Estlink 2 electricity interconnector cable between Estonia and Finland on December 25, 2024Finland Police

Finland is also continuing to pursue a case against the officers of Eagle S, the Cook Islands-flagged tanker that severed the Estlink 2 power cable between Finland and Estonia on Christmas Day in 2024 after its anchor dragged for over 40 nautical miles in the Baltic when it was (surprise) underway from Russia.

The Georgian master of the vessel, Davit Vadatchkoria, was interviewed in English by Yle's Swedish-language unit here, and he claimed that the incident was all a big misunderstanding and an unfortunate accident as he said that he and the Eagle S crew had simply not noticed the anchor dragging along the seabed.

For a while it looked like the Finnish authorities would be impotent to hold anyone accountable for the damage. In October last year, the Helsinki District Court dismissed charges of sabotage against Vadatchkoria and two other officers, concluding it was not authorised to judge in the case because the alleged actions occurred in international waters not within Finland’s 12-nautical-mile territorial waters.

In its decision, the district court stated that the criminal jurisdiction lies with the courts in the flag state of the tanker (the mighty Cook Islands) or in the countries where the defendants are citizens (Georgia and India). The Sweden Herald reported that the trial cost the Finnish state around US$200,000 and that the Finnish Government had to reimburse the trial costs of the accused seafarers.

But… that 2025 verdict was not the final verdict, as the prosecution appealed against the decision. On August 27, 2026, the Finnish Court of Appeal overturned the District Court’s decision and concluded that Finland’s jurisdiction could be established in the Eagles S case, because the acts committed in the Finnish exclusive economic zone had consequences in Finland. Thus, the act could thus be deemed to have occurred in Finland under national legislation, which it observed to be consistent with international law.

Also Read
COLUMN | Escape and evasion: the damaging aspect of flags of convenience [Grey Power]

The appeal court concluded that whilst the initial dropping of the anchor and the resulting submarine cable damage might be considered unintentional and accidental, as Captain Vadatchkoria claimed, what happened afterwards was not. The court referred to the fact that the anchor continued dragging for several hours, that the vessel slowed down after Finnish authorities contacted the ship regarding the anchor and that the crew allegedly provided the coast guard with false information, all of which appeared to be deliberate acts rather than an unfortunate navigational accident.

The appeal court decision can be appealed to the Supreme Court by the crew. Otherwise, the case will be retried in the district court and the two Georgians and the Indian mate will be back in court again, a lengthy, inconvenient and stressful process regardless of the outcome.

America sanctions fake flag sellers

Whilst shadow fleet crewmembers have been at the forefront of legal action against the tankers carrying sanctioned oil from Russia and Iran, we have highlighted the role of the flag states that register the shadow fleet vessels, often turning a blind eye to old and substandard tonnage, opaque ownership structures and flag hopping as ships move from register to register to try to circumvent sanctions.

Now the US Government body responsible for sanctions, the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC), has clamped down on the operators of several of these registries. Tommy Piggot, spokesman for OFAC, had some words about this development:

“For more than a decade, India-based Suniel Kumar Sharma and his wife, Jaspreet Preeti Shahid, have formed companies that pose as the flag registries and maritime service providers of countries and jurisdictions such as Guyana, Eswatini, Aruba, Mali, Mozambique, Malawi, Sint Maarten and Timor-Leste. These companies have sold fraudulent registrations and certificates to vessels carrying illicit Iranian oil. Most of these governments have publicly disavowed the fraudulent registries.”

Thanks to Michelle Wiese Bockmann for drawing attention to the various scams run by Suniel Kumar Sharma long before he appeared in the crosshairs of OFAC. Windward’s excellent analysis of the impact of the fake flags run by Mr Kumar and their prevalence is here. The report made the following conclusion:

“Ships flying false flags lack valid insurance and certificates of seaworthiness and safety from recognised organizations. This poses significant threats to maritime safety, security, the environment, and endangers crew welfare. In effect, these vessels operate as lawless and stateless actors.”

The fact that bad actors can continue to abuse the flag state registry system undermines the whole of maritime governance across the world. As we have seen above, fake flags, low-quality flags and registries run for private profit by dubious individuals jeopardise not only the marine environment, but also the lives of seafarers, in terms of both safety risk and legal risk.

The IMO should be much firmer in deterring its members from allowing foreign-incorporated private companies to operate international registries on their behalf without enforcing technical standards, oversight of ultimate beneficial ownership, and greater compliance with international maritime laws. From the Fonzi scandal in Turkey to Baltic cable cutting and fake flagging, vigilance is essential.

Without rules and their enforcement, the world quickly slips into anarchy and crookery. Groups as diverse as Turkish investors, Guyanese government officials, and Georgian ship’s officers have discovered this to their detriment.

Background reading

Oh no! Kazakhstan’s anti-corruption service detained the heads of both the country’s sovereign wealth fund and its national railway operator on suspicion of a corruption offense last week. The detained officials are Nurlan Zhakupov, the head of the US$87.5 billion Samruk-Kazyna Sovereign Fund, and Yelzhas Otynshiyev, head of the national railway company Kazakhstan Temir Zholy, which is owned by the fund.

As well as its comprehensive coverage of Georgian and Azerbaijani ship managers working for the shadow fleet, iFact also published an analysis of the role of Georgian ports in the transit of sanctioned Russian oil, looking at systematic signal manipulation and cargo blending by tankers calling in Georgia waters from Russia.

The Blog of the European Journal of International Law has an analysis of the appeal by prosecutors on the Eagle S case here. DLA Piper’s case summary is here.