

Caledonian Maritime Assets (CMAL) chief executive Kevin Hobbs told the Scottish Parliament's Transport Committee on Wednesday, November 18, that the company's board opposed a direct award of new ferry work to Ferguson Marine.
The work is the second phase of the small vessels replacement programme and involves two or perhaps three electric powered ferries for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra.
Hobbs said CMAL wanted an open international tender. In his view a direct award was not currently lawful, although planned changes to CMAL's governance could make one possible in 2027.
Asked whether he would prefer the work not to be awarded directly, Hobbs said: "100 per cent. We have written to the government and told them that." He added: "Those ships really need to arrive in a very, very timely manner."
State-owned Ferguson Marine has faced years of delays and major cost overruns on two dual-fuel ferries ordered by CMAL in 2015, Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa, whose combined cost escalated from £97 million ($127 million) to more than £400 million. Originally due in 2018, Glen Sannox was delivered more than six years late in November 2024, while Glen Rosa suffered repeated pushbacks into 2026.
Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Tourism and Transport Stephen Flynn said ministers remained committed to the direct awards proposed in March. Transport Scotland chief executive Alison Irvine said due diligence should be completed by the end of March 2027.
The hearing also raised doubts about whether Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa will run on gas. Both ferries can use either marine gas oil (MGO) or liquefied natural gas (LNG). Hobbs said LNG had become hugely expensive.
CalMac Ferries chief executive Duncan Mackison said: "There is a question mark. It will hinge on the investment case to put LNG facilities to where that vessel will run from."
Glen Sannox was redeployed to the Western Isles, where LNG refuelling is unavailable, before its annual overhaul scheduled for November 16. Glen Rosa is running on diesel ahead of a handover that CMAL is targeting for February 26, 2027.
Poland's Remontowa Shipbuilding won the contract to build the seven first-phase ferries through a competitive tender in March 2025.