MSC Poesia MSC Cruises
Cruise

US official says criminal probe underway into alleged oil discharges from MSC cruise ship

Several crewmembers reportedly stayed in Miami for questioning as the ship resumed Caribbean sailings, following a detention that forced the operator to cancel a voyage with over 2,000 people on board.

Gareth Havelock

The US Coast Guard has opened a criminal investigation into alleged illegal oil discharges at sea from the cruise ship MSC Poesia, an official familiar with the case told CBS News.

The official described a possible "magic pipe" arrangement in which oil was diverted into the ship's grey water system.

According to CBS News, the investigation could extend to crewmembers, the vessel's owner, and others directly involved who might bear criminal liability. No charges have yet been filed.

MSC Poesia departed PortMiami on Thursday, November 12, on a 10-night round-trip Caribbean voyage.

A Coast Guard Sector Miami port state control team detained the ship after inspecting it on November 1. The coast guard authorised her to sail only once it confirmed that the safety and environmental deficiencies that prompted the detention had been corrected.

"The coast guard cannot currently comment on the specifics of an ongoing port state control examination, but we have identified deficiencies with systems on board the vessel that we are addressing with MSC," said Captain Frank Florio, commander of Coast Guard Sector Miami.

MSC Cruises cancelled the affected sailing, citing a regulatory matter that could not be resolved before departure, and offered passengers full refunds. More than 2,000 people were on board when the ship was detained.

The company has said it is fully cooperating with authorities.

Under the Act to Prevent Pollution from Ships (APPS), which implements MARPOL in US law, a knowing violation is a Class D felony carrying up to six years' imprisonment. Federal fines reach US$250,000 per offence for individuals and US$500,000 for organisations, or up to twice the gain or loss resulting from the offence.

A vessel operated in violation of APPS is also liable in rem for the resulting fines.

The act allows departure clearance to be withheld where liability is suspected but states that, "clearance may be granted upon the filing of a bond or other surety satisfactory to the secretary."

MSC Poesia moved to Miami for the winter 2026/2027 season after operating from Seattle.