37-year freshwater salmon farming study indicates environmental impact fears are overblown

Mowi Scotland has announced findings from a 37-year continuous independent water quality monitoring programme that found that salmon farming in freshwater lochs did not alter the nutrient status of the water body.

The study was carried out at Loch Arkaig, where Mowi farmed salmon for almost 40 years. Earlier this year, Mowi announced that it would no longer be farming salmon at Loch Arkaig and now the company has compiled a report based on continuous water quality monitoring, which commenced in 1987 at this location, to better understand the impact of operation of the fish farm.

“With the recent closure of our Loch Arkaig fish farm, it is only right to look back on our operations extending to almost 40 years, with a particular focus on the nutrient status of the water body, to better understand any potential impact from salmon farming," said Stephen MacIntyre, Head of Environment at Mowi Scotland.

“The data set which extends for 37 years shows that the geometric mean for phosphorus levels in Loch Arkaig has remained stable and within its trophic status.

"Whilst phosphorus level is the principal nutrient controlling the nutrient status of the loch, its values vary throughout the year due to land management in the catchment and rainfall levels. It is therefore important to invest in monthly sampling and establish a long running data set to establish a geometric mean.

“Loch Arkaig has been officially classified by SEPA as a water body of 'high ecological' status. This means that the water at Loch Arkaig is unaffected or virtually unaffected by human activity.”

Over the last 37 years, water samples have been taken regularly from Loch Arkaig by a team from the University of Stirling. These water samples were then analysed in the lab.

The aim of the monitoring is to assess the nutrient status of the water body to ensure there is no change in ecological status with the key parameters analysed including total phosphorus (TP) and chlorophyll-a (Chl-a).

This continuous water quality monitoring programme is not unique to Loch Arkaig. This research is also being undertaken at Mowi’s freshwater farms at Loch Ness, Loch Lochy, Loch Garry, Loch Shiel and Loch Awe. The data is similarly used to monitor and track the nutrient status of these water bodies.

These findings on freshwater quality follow Mowi’s groundbreaking study in 2024 when a three-year post-closure environmental study was conducted around Mowi’s former Isle of Ewe fish farm on the north west coast of Scotland. The study provided solid evidence that seabeds can recover upon cessation of fish farming operations.