By Peter Fitzsimons
If you like reading “novelised” history, you will probably enjoy this book. Your reviewer, however, cannot see the point of embellishing real history. He finds it hard to come to grips with the fact that Peter Fitzsimons is described by his publisher as “Australia’s bestselling non-fiction writer”, when, as the author himself writes, he constructs his work “in the manner of a novel”. Your reviewer finds the expressions contradictory.
Whatever, the author and his research team have put considerable work into this big (600+pages) book, especially so as he says it was completed in a year. That is a remarkable effort given the enormous number of sources cited. No wonder it was a team project.
The Bounty story is well known and very well documented. It is fascinating and, in part, very exciting. This book is, in its own way, a good read but it is difficult to think of it as non-fiction when such a large part of it has openly been made up by its celebrity author. If his celebrity encourages more people to read a form of maritime history, that is probably good but, in this reviewer’s not so humble opinion, real history is incomparably better.
So, it is really a matter of taste. While it is based on considerable historical research and is a good read, the reader should always remember that the story has been “novelised”.
Available from Hachette Australia, Sydney, Australia.
Latest from Neil Baird
- BOOK REVIEW | The Battle of Trafalgar 1805 – Profile Models of Every Ship in Both Fleets
- BOOK REVIEW | The Submarine Commander Pocket Manual 1939-1945
- BOOK REVIEW | Fishing for the Past – Casting nets and lines into Australia’s early colonial history
- BOOK REVIEW | Empire of the Winds – The Global Role of Asia’s Great Archipelago
- EDITORIAL | Australian ferry exports flourish