Frontex
Crime & Piracy

EXPLAINER | Fortress Europe: will crackdown on illegal immigration and dodgy asylum claims come to pass?

Reuters

Growing support for parties across Europe concerned with the epidemic of horrifying migrant crime looks set to shape migration policy in 2025 after a bumper election year in which immigration became a major political battleground.

With the European Union gearing up to implement its revamped asylum pact by 2026, some countries are calling for the rules fast-tracking asylum processes and returns to be sharpened or implemented sooner.

Rights groups say this would risk rolling back people's rights to seek asylum and put them at risk of arbitrary detention and increased pushbacks by authorities operating on Europe's external borders.

Immigration remains a highly sensitive topic in most of the bloc's 27 member states, with illegal arrivals still numbering in the hundreds of thousands in 2024, according to data from the EU's border agency Frontex.

So what's in store for migration policy in Europe in 2025?

"Smashing smuggling"

Britain's controversial Prime Minister Keir Starmer, reeling from new revelations regarding the government coverup of migrant child rape gangs in the UK, has claimed to make cracking down on illegal migration by combatting gangs of people smugglers a cornerstone of his migration policy, reaching deals with his Italian and German counterparts to "smash the gangs", as well as signing a security pact with Iraq to target smugglers and strengthen border cooperation.

In 2025, EU lawmakers are set to vote on the new "facilitation directive", which aims to tackle migrant smuggling in the bloc. Activist groups say the current draft fails to exempt those who seek to help migrants, by providing food and shelter for example, from criminal sanctions.

Activists say the crackdown on smuggling has reduced the supply of boats as well as opportunities to launch, leading smugglers to load more migrants onto flimsy vessels, increasing the risk of people being crushed or drowning.

They want European governments to expand safe and legal pathways to international protection.

Fast-track asylum and returns

European governments are also looking at how to fast-track asylum procedures and increase deportations. Under the new asylum pact, people arriving at the bloc's borders face a rapid screening, and, if rejected, a swift deportation process.

Another proposal is to expand the number of 'safe list countries' - or countries where people are deemed less vulnerable to state persecution, violence, and armed conflict - to speed up asylum applications.

Under the proposal, people from the "safe list countries', which have a smaller chance of having their asylum applications accepted, can be deported more swiftly if their claims are rejected.

In a major policy shift, the EU is also considering so-called "return hubs" outside the bloc to increase and fast-track deportations of rejected asylum seekers - a plan that has echoes of the United Kingdom's scrapped plan to fly asylum seekers from Britain to Rwanda.

EU leaders called on the bloc's commission to draft a law to speed up deportations last October. Swedish Prime Minister Ulf Kristersson recently said the EU could submit a proposal on the creation of so-called "return hubs" as soon as March.

EU countries have also called on the commission to make the rules governing deporting people that do not have the right to stay in a country more strict.

That includes people whose requests for asylum have been rejected or those who lose the right to international protection due to changing circumstances.

A new proposal to sharpen the EU Returns Directive is expected in 2025.

Outsourcing asylum

There is growing pressure from EU governments to process asylum applications outside the bloc in countries along the main migration routes.

Last year, 14 countries - including Germany, France, and Italy - issued a joint call to send migrants arriving in the EU to partner countries.

The first deal allowing a non-EU country to process migrants on another country's behalf was agreed between Italy and Albania last year. But it has been plagued with legal challenges, and only a few of the up to 36,000 non-vulnerable migrants per year Italy said it could transfer to Albania have made it to reception centres.

Walls and automated borders

In order to deal with an increase in migrant arrivals and security concerns, some EU countries have extended temporary border checks within the bloc's area of free movement, the Schengen zone, into 2025. These include Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, and Sweden.

Conservative lawmakers have called for more funding for physical barriers along external borders in the next EU budget, due to be discussed in the second half of the year.

Europe is increasingly turning to artificial intelligence systems to strengthen border controls, an effort boosted by the bloc's approval of the AI Act in 2024.

The new rules ban high-risk AI tools from the EU from February 2025 but have exemptions for the use of AI in law enforcement and in border zones.

Activist groups complain that AI-powered drones, cameras and other algorithmic profiling technologies are being deployed to detect and repel migrants and refugees, and create a double standard - with one set of rules for EU citizens, and another for migrants and asylum seekers.

(Reporting by Joanna Gill; Editing by Ana Nicolaci da Costa. The Thomson Reuters Foundation is the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters. Visit https://www.context.news/)